17–0
Play
64Overall
QBBig 12

McCae Hillstead

BYU · Quarterback · 2024-25

PASS YDS
33
PASS TD
0
RUSH TD
0

Career totals · 1 season with stats

Scouting Report

In 2025, Hillstead threw for 33 yards.

In 17-0 that career earns a 64 overall, the 17th-highest quarterback rating at BYU since 1990 and No. 74 among all quarterbacks of the 2025-Present era.

Season by Season

McCae Hillstead season-by-season statistics at BYU
SeasonPass YdsRush Yds
20253328

Seasons with tracked stats at BYU. Coverage starts in 2006; tackles, sacks and passes defended start in 2016 (shown as – before then).

BYU Teammates

  1. 83LJ Martin2023-26RB
  2. 77Isaiah Glasker2022-25LB
  3. 75Evan Johnson2022-25CB
  4. 74Tanner Wall2022-25S
  5. 72Faletau Satuala2024-25S
  6. 72Jack Kelly2024-25LB
  7. 72Carsen Ryan2025TE
  8. 71Parker Kingston2022-25WR
  9. 71Bear Bachmeier2025QB
  10. 70Chase Roberts2021-25WR

Full BYU all-time roster

Top Quarterbacks of the 2025-Present Era

  1. 97Fernando MendozaIndiana · 2025QB
  2. 91Diego PaviaVanderbilt · 2024-25QB
  3. 86Julian SayinOhio State · 2024-25QB
  4. 83Haynes KingGeorgia Tech · 2023-25QB
  5. 83Trinidad ChamblissOle Miss · 2025QB
  6. 80Gunner StocktonGeorgia · 2022-26QB
  7. 75Cade KlubnikClemson · 2022-25QB
  8. 75Demond Williams Jr.Washington · 2024-26QB

Best college quarterbacks since 1990Best Big 12 players

Sources: Wikipedia and its All-America, all-conference, award and program statistical-leader pages; season statistics and NFL Draft data from CollegeFootballData.com. Ratings are 17-0's own estimates, graded within each era. How ratings work.